ABOUT HOSTS

Joe Anderson
ABOUT Joseph

As CEO, Joe Anderson, CFP®, AIF®, has created a unique, ambitious business model utilizing advanced service, training, sales, and marketing strategies to grow Pure Financial Advisors into the trustworthy, client-focused company it is today. Pure Financial, a Registered Investment Advisor (RIA), was named one of Inc. Magazine’s 2026 Best Workplaces, ranked #27 out of 50 [...]

Alan Clopine
ABOUT Alan

Alan Clopine is the Your Money, Your Wealth® Podcast Co-Host at Pure Financial Advisors, LLC (Pure). He has served as an executive leader at the Company for over a decade, including as CFO, CEO, and Chairman. Alan joined the firm in 2008, about one year after it was established. In his tenure at Pure, the [...]

Andi Last
ABOUT Andi

Andi Last brings over 30 years of broadcasting, media, and marketing experience to Pure Financial Advisors. Serving as Media Manager remotely, Andi is based in South Australia. She is Executive Producer of the Your Money, Your Wealth® podcast, manages the firm's YouTube channels, and is involved in the production and distribution of the Your Money, [...]

Published On
November 17, 2026

Should you both retire at 62, even if it means one of you retires four years before the other? That’s what Joe and Big Al are spitballing for Louden and Carla today on Your Money, Your Wealth podcast number 608. Judith Iscariot is retiring at 57 with a $130,000 pension and her husband Brian Cohen is a very naughty boy. No, actually, Brian is working until 65, but $70,000 in credit card debt is keeping him up at night. Should he cut back on retirement savings to pay it down? Finally, Roger in California is 57, single, and wants to move his retirement up three years. Should he switch from Roth to traditional in his 401(k)? And should talk of capping Social Security benefits change when he claims?

What are the pros and cons of a staggered retirement, where one spouse retires before the other?

In a staggered retirement, one spouse retires while the other keeps working for a few more years. The working spouse’s paycheck and health coverage can reduce how much you pull from savings, and the lower-income years may open room for Roth conversions. The biggest tradeoff is personal: both spouses need to actually want the plan.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you calculate your retirement distribution rate?
Take your annual spending, subtract fixed income like Social Security and pensions, and divide what’s left by your total portfolio. That percentage is your distribution rate. A rate in the 6% to 7% range can feel tight, especially if markets drop early, while a rate closer to 4% or 5% may leave more cushion.

Should I cut retirement contributions to pay off credit card debt?
A common approach is to contribute at least enough to get any employer match, then put extra cash toward the debt. The risk is that paid-down card balances creep back up, leaving you with the same debt and less saved, so this approach may work best when spending stays disciplined.

What’s the difference between the debt snowball and debt avalanche methods?
The snowball method pays off your smallest balance first, then rolls that payment into the next smallest, which can build momentum. The avalanche method pays off the highest interest rate first, which generally costs less in total interest. The better choice may be whichever one you’ll actually stick with.

Should I switch from Roth to traditional 401(k) contributions before I retire?
If most of your savings is already in Roth accounts and you’re in a higher bracket while working, traditional contributions give you a tax deduction now. You may then be able to withdraw that money in a lower bracket in early retirement, for example to cover the years before a pension or Social Security begins.

Should I claim Social Security early because of proposed benefit cuts?
Proposals to change Social Security don’t always become law, so changing your claiming strategy based on one could backfire. Claiming before full retirement age permanently reduces your monthly benefit, and you can’t claim retirement benefits before 62. It may make sense to wait until changes are real and then review your plan with experienced professionals.

Follow the YMYW podcast Subscribe to the YMYW newsletter

Show Notes

  • 00:00 – Intro: This Week on the YMYW Podcast
  • 00:59 – Staggered Retirement: Should We Retire 4 Years Apart? (Louden & Carla, Wadsworth, OH)
  • 13:40 – Pay Off $270K of Debt or Keep Maxing My 401(k)? (Brian & Judith, Chicago, IL)
  • 27:25 – Too Much Roth? When to Switch Back to a Pre-Tax 401(k) (Roger Thornhill/George Kaplan, CA)
  • 35:16 – Outro: Next Week on the YMYW Podcast
  • 37:15 – The Derails: Vision Quest, Monty Python trivia, and North by Northwest

Free Financial Resources: 

Social Security Handbook – free download

Financial Blueprint – free, self-guided

Financial Football: Get in the Game – YMYW TV

Guides | Blogs | Educational Videos | YMYW Newsletter | Subscribe on YouTube

Free Financial Assessment

Watch today’s podcast episode on YouTube

Retire at 62 With $3.6M While Your Spouse Keeps Working? - Your Money, Your Wealth® podcast 608

Transcription

(NOTE: Transcriptions are an approximation and may not be entirely correct)

Intro: This Week on the YMYW Podcast

Andi: Should you both retire at 62, even if it means one of you retires four years before the other? That’s what Joe and Big Al are spitballing for Louden and Carla today on Your Money, Your Wealth podcast number 608. Judith Iscariot is retiring at 57 with a $130,000 pension and her husband Brian Cohen is a very naughty boy. No, actually, Brian is working until 65, but $70,000 in credit card debt is keeping him up at night. Should he cut back on retirement savings to pay it down? Finally, Roger in California is 57, single, and wants to move his retirement up three years. Should he switch from Roth to traditional in his 401(k)? And should talk of capping Social Security benefits change when he claims? Help others find us making fun of finance over here on YMYW by leaving your honest ratings and reviews for us in Apple Podcasts. I’m Executive Producer Andi Last and here are the hosts of Your Money, Your Wealth®, Joe Anderson, CFP® and Big Al Clopine, CPA.

Staggered Retirement: Should We Retire 4 Years Apart? (Louden & Carla, Wadsworth, OH)

Joe: All right, we got Louden and Carla. Anyone?

Andi: Do you know that one?

Joe: Wadsworth?

Al: No, I have no idea.

Andi: From the movie Vision Quest from 1985.

Joe: Oh, that’s a great movie. That’s the wrestler.

Andi: Yes.

Joe: All right, Joe, Big Al, Andi. “Thanks for all the information and entertainment you guys do every week. I’ve been listening for the past three years and have gone back to catch up on many older episodes as well.” Okay, one of those guys.

“We’re in Northeast Ohio and are planning to both retire at 62, but we’re staggering by four years. I’m Louden, 59, and my wife, Carla, 55. The fun stuff first, Carla is a Pinot Grigio fan and I’m a bourbon guy. Currently about 145 different kinds, 195 bottles total.”

Andi: Wow.

Al: Wow.

Joe: Boo.

Al: Okay.

Joe: Louden.

Al: That’s, a lot.

Joe: Where in Northeast Ohio do you live? Yeah.

Andi: He- it’s just outside of Akron. It, the town of Wadsworth has got, 24,000 people in it.

Al: Got it.

Joe: He’s got 145 bottles of bourbon?

Al: That’s a lot.

Andi: That’s what he said.

Joe: We could sing like 145, 45 bottles of bourbon on the wall. Bottles of bourbon on the wall. And then just cash ’em down.

Al: Cash ’em down,

Joe: Pass it around.

All right.

Al: I don’t think he’d make it to the end.

Joe: I don’t think so either. 195 bottles total. Yep. Jeez. All right, car-wise, I have a 2025 Honda Passport. Love the new body style.

Andi: Actually, that’s her car.

Joe: And then… Oh, that’s her car. That’s her car, yeah. Oh, Car- she’s got it.

She’s got it, yeah. Yes. Okay. And I’m driving a 2019 Ford F-350. That’s a big daddy. It’s a little diesel long bed, over 22 feet long and no parking deck friendly. That guy must have a terrible time parking that beast.

Al: You wouldn’t take that to the grocery store, I don’t think.

Joe: No, Trip to Target, forget about it.

You could load up, you got the bed for it, but-

Al: You could. you’d have to park a mile away.

Joe: You would.

Al: Walk.

Joe: Yep. “We’re also looking for a retirement home in Michigan or Ohio. Our current home is worth about a million dollars. It’s paid off, and we expect to net roughly $700,000 after we sell it.

We’re building a healthy down payment for our retirement house now.” “Here’s our main question. What are the pros and cons of staggering a retirement? Me retiring at 62, her continuing to work until she’s 62, so four years later.” On the plus side, we’ll have four more years of her income, and I can go on her health insurance until I reach 65.

Then we’d cover gap insurance for her for roughly three years until she hits 65. We feel good about our savings, and we also expect an inheritance as an additional buffer. We’d love your perspective on the trade-offs, planning opportunities, and pitfalls we should be thinking about with this staggering approach.

Tax planning, Social Security timing, healthcare, withdrawal, et cetera.” Man, this guy wants the whole- He does … the caboodle.

Al: Yeah, this could take a while.

Joe: This could. if you would like to give us a little spitball, I have also included some information below. Keep up the good work. Louden and Carla.” All right, so they got some savings here.

Carla’s got 350, Louden’s got a million, and then he’s got an ESOP plan worth another $900,000 that he projected in 2029. They got a joint brokerage account of 250 grand. Carla’s got a Roth IRA of 400. Louden’s got one of 8,000. they got some HSA plans. Cash savings, from the sale of their home is 700,000, will be invested conservatively to mitigate taxes and future growth.

$50,000 of working capital or emergency. So their Social Security, Louden’s 42,000, Carla’s will be 22. Pension, Carla will be 25, no COLA. And then inheritance, Louden’s thinking he’s gonna get about a million bucks. So let’s see. What do they wanna spend? Current spending $120,000 a year, retirement spending 225.

Al: Yep.

Joe: So his main question is the staggering approach.

Al: yeah. So I think first let’s see if it, how this looks number-wise.

Joe: Okay.

Al: So I ran that. It’s kinda hard to run this multiple ways. I just ran a what if they both retire at his age, 59, just see how this works, right? So they’re at about $2 million right now.

Joe: but he’s asking, he retire at 62. I know. Both… Him 62, her 59?

Al: Yeah, both at 62.

Joe: Okay.

Al: But I did it, he retires at 62- Sure … her at 58.

Joe: Okay.

Al: Just to see what that looks like.

Joe: yes.

Al: Good. Okay. Got it.

Joe: Yes. Okay. I’m with you.

Al: I’m sorry. Okay. they’re saving about 58,000 a year. So they end up with 2.7 million, adding 900,000 to that on the ESOP, assuming that comes out-

or gets rolled- Yep … I guess, into the retirement account. So that’s 3.6 million.

Joe: Okay.

Al: Then I looked at the, like, they wanna spend 225 in retirement, and so I, inflated that for three years. I get 246,000. 246 into 3.6 million is a 6.8% distribution rate, so it’s, that’s, that, that’s probably a little bit tight.

Joe: Did you subtract out the pensions and Social Security?

Al: Not yet.

Joe: Okay.

Al: ‘Cause it hasn’t, but we’ll get there. So the bridge. The bridge. So you’re building a bridge at 62.

Yes.

Joe: She’s 58. We got fixed income coming in- Yeah … certain.

Al: That’s right.

Joe: Got it.

Al: So, if they kept the same spending, they’d, their spending would now be 131,000.

That’s a 3.6% distribution rate. They could s- they could spend more than that. They might even be able to spend what they want to with the fixed income. Now, the fixed income will happen at four years from then, and that’ll be 89,000. So that, that covers a lot, really. And I didn’t really run with her adding…

I, think this works, I guess, is the point. And I, the first question is it the pros and cons of staggered retirement. It, it’s always better when one spouse is still working financially, but is that really, what they wanna do?

Joe: Well, I think the pro is, yeah, the staggering approach is really good for the financials.

Al: Yes.

Joe: But is it, or-

Al: That’s-

Joe: … if one person’s still grinding and one person’s retired-

Al: That, then that’s- …

Joe: how happy are both of you gonna be,

Al: That’s the question. Yeah. that’s why I ran it the way I did- Yeah … because I w- I wanted to see could it work if they both retired. And, I think it does. If it were me personally, I probably wouldn’t spend 225.

I’d probably tone it down for four years just for the bridge, but then I think they can probably spend at that level.

Joe: Yeah, I totally agree. So-

Al: But if they do the staggered approach, how does that affect Social Security, healthcare, withdrawals, all of that?

Joe: Well, the four years that she’s working, there’s probably very little withdrawals because she still has an income.

Al: Agreed. Yep. All right? So, so it just keeps growing.

Joe: Yeah. So, and when you have one person- working, you’re not saving anymore, so th- and you’re in a lower tax bracket. So the tax strategy would probably be looking at Roth conversions over those period of time. You’d just have to, you know, pay the tax there. Social Security timing, you push that off as long as you can. Your healthcare, if she’s still working, you’re going on hers, and then you just have the bridge. So he knows the pros of staggering.

Al: Yeah, he does.

Joe: He- the, the con of not, if you both retire at, you’re age 62, is that it’s gonna be more expensive.

You have four more years where you’re drawing down from your overall portfolio.

Al: And you’re paying health insurance.

Joe: And you’re paying health insurance.

And, you know, there’s a bridge, a lot longer bridge until you get your fixed income sources from your Social Security and your pensions.

Al: Correct.

Joe: And so 100% of that 225 or whatever dollar figure that you wanna spend is coming from your overall investable assets. And if markets do what they do, you know, that’s a big burn rate. You know? It is. You’re pulling 6 or 7%. Yeah. Even though in a few years you’re going to have fixed income where that distribution rate’s gonna be a lot smaller.

Al: But if the market turns and you lose 10, 15, 20% of the portfolio, that 6% is now 8%. It’s hard to get caught back up, and I think the, the nerves and anxiety that money does for people when they have to pull that much money from their liquid portfolio, it’s like, “Oh man, now should we go back to work?”

Joe: Yeah. And then you’re kinda playing that whole game.

Al: I 100% agree. I think it gets emotional at that point wh- it, just feels like your, portfolio’s shrinking too quickly.

Joe: Yes.

Al: And so if she works, then that would preserve that, and then by the time she gets to 62, he’d be on Medicare. She would have to pay for insurance for three years- but she could take Social Security. He could take Social Security. Her pension kicks in, and I think, I mean, that’s, ideal. I’m just concerned, does she want to?

Joe: I mean, he’s writing in. Does she know about this? Does she know about the plan?

Al: yeah, is this her plan or is this his?

Joe: Yeah.

Al: it’s like, “Honey, I worked to 62. You’re, you gotta do it, too.”

Joe: Yep, yep, I think, so y- he’s, th- they got three years.

Al: Yep.

Joe: So continue to do what you’re doing. Keep saving as much as you’re saving. Be diligent. and then when you get closer, see how you really feel about, all right, do you really wanna pull the plug? But running the numbers right now, I think financially it works both ways. It works a lot better with her working.

Al: Correct.

Joe: it’s tight, and there’s a lot of things that can go wrong-  if you both retire when Loudon retires, but I think- Like, I agree with you. I think they can do it.

Al: Yeah.

Joe: But there’s a lot more planning, a lot more, you know- No, I think- … discipline involved there. It’s going to be a little bit rougher road.

Al: I think you said it perfectly. I think you, you work three years. you reassess. Where are you? does this, you know, do the numbers still work? does she wanna retire at the same time, and how does this look? Yeah. What can you really spend? Maybe you’re not spending the 225. Maybe you’re spending something in between.

Joe: 190.

Al: Yeah, 150, 170, 180. You run the numbers then. I just looked at, well, what if they spent 175? Now, that’s future dollars but still, it’s pretty close. That’s a under 5% distribution rate. I’d be okay with that because the fixed income’s coming in four years later.

Joe: Yep. Yeah, a lot to think about. a lot- love the question, but yeah, I think you can do both. But it’s like, keep doing what you’re doing. Back of your mind, you’re like, “Okay, work is optional for both of us in a couple of years.”

Al: Let’s reassess when we get, you know, maybe two and, two and a half years from now, see how this looks, see what the market’s done, see about her job. Maybe he’ll wanna work another year. He- you don’t know.

Joe: Yeah, you never know.

Al: Yeah.

Joe: but they’ve done a great job saving. They have. Th- they- they’ve done the, thought process, they’re planning.

Al: Yeah. No, they- he’s got it pretty dialed in already.

Joe: Yeah, for sure. He knows the pros.

Al: He does.

Joe: He just wants-

Al: He wants us to see

Joe: what- To say, “Yeah. Well, you know, no, let her do… No, she, definitely needs to keep working.”

Al: That’s what he wanted.

Joe: That does, yeah, that’s what he wanted to hear. See, honey? Let’s listen to this over, candlelight dinner tonight.

Andi: After they tell you have to continue working.

Joe: Yes.

Al: Except we didn’t really say that, so he may not play it back.

Joe: Yeah, probably not.

Al: Yeah. Yeah.

Andi: Louden and Carla have a game plan: he retires first, she keeps working, and they hand off four years later. Whether that play works comes down to the same two questions just about everyone who writes in to YMYW is asking: do we have enough, and how much can we actually spend? It’s football season, so on YMYW TV, Joe and Big Al are calling plays in an episode called Financial Football: Get in the Game. They cover building a retirement game plan, savings by age, the Hail Mary strategies people reach for when they’re behind, and how to course correct before the clock runs out. Then run your own play. Our free, self-guided Financial Blueprint takes just a few minutes, from your couch if you want. Plug in your age, your savings, your income, and the lifestyle you want in retirement, and it will build you a personalized snapshot: what you’ve got now, what you’ll need later, and any gaps you need to fill in between. You get a range, from a likely minimum to your comfortable target to a maximum, with the tradeoffs spelled out. No cost, no obligation. Just click or tap the links in the episode description to watch Financial Football on YMYW TV, and calculate your own free Financial Blueprint.

Pay Off $270K of Debt or Keep Maxing My 401(k)? (Brian & Judith, Chicago, IL)

Joe: All right, let’s go to, I don’t know where we’re going here. Another pay off debt, theme we got going here. Oh, yeah.

Andi: This one is Brian Cohen and Judith Iscariot from the movie, The Life of Brian. Monty Python.

Al: Oh, okay.

Joe: Okay. All right. hey, so let’s see. We got Brian Cohen in Judith Iscaria. “Here in northwest suburb of Chicago. Been listening for a few years. I really enjoy the show and hoping for a quick spitball.

I’m 57, my wife’s 53, and we make a combined $210,000 a year. My wife will retire at age 57 with $130,000 pension, 67% transfer, to me if something horrible happens. COLA starts at 62, and plans to get a part-time job once she’s retired. Thinking about 15 to $20,000 per year.” “She is not eligible for Social Security, so we’ll claim the spousal benefit from my $38,000 a year when I turn 65.

I currently have $700,000 in my retirement account, $100,000 in a Roth, and I contribute $30,000 a year, limit plus the catch-up to my traditional. We have $2000 in a brokerage account, $5000 in a savings account earning 4%, and $50,000 in a 529 account. I view the pension as our fixed income savings, so my retirement is split between various stock funds.

We currently spend about $180,000 a year and would like to end up at $200,000 after taxes in today’s dollars when I retire. Our home is, our home has a $300,000 mortgage, and it’s appraised at $750,000. We have about $70,000 in old debt on credit cards. I do a 4% balance transfer dance yearly, to keep it at 0%.

And we have about $200,000 in student loan once the kids are done with school, once the 529 funds are factored in. we currently are paying down our total debt of about $5000 per year. I currently plan to work until age 65. The debt stresses me, so part of me thinks I should lessen my retirement contributions to pay off more debt.

Another thought I have is that since we live in Illinois, which does not ta- tax retirement income, it might make sense to keep fully funded my traditional accounts to the yearly limit, including catch-up, and using $50,000 distributions when I turn 59 and a half, and also add the following year to pay off $100,000 in credit card loan debt instead of converting to Roth in those two years, increasing my withholdings to cover the tax.

Then start on Roth conversions from 61 until retirement using some withholding increase.” All right, let’s see. All right. “My j- drink of choice is light beer. My wife prefers a Pinot. We have two kids, 19 and 16, a scooter noodle- … and we have three cars all paid off. My wife drives-

Andi: That was schnoodle, by the way.

Joe: A scannonoodle.

Al: I, I like scoo- scooter

noodle.

Scooter noodle. Scooter noodle.

Joe: It’s a scooter noodle. “We drive a 2018 Sienna. My daughter and son drive a 2010 Outlander, and I drive a piece of crap 2008 Aveo.” What the hell is- Never heard of Aveo … a 2008 Aveo?

Andi: Let me find out for you.

Joe: I’ve never heard of an Aveo.

Al: And I’m guessing it’s a little-

Andi: I think it’s a Chevy, and I think it’s a Aveo. yeah, it’s a Chevy. Oh. And-

Al: Aveo …

Joe: Ave- Yeah … oh, Aveo sounds cool. Well, yeah, Aveo. The Aveo, it’s like a piece of crap.

Andi: It’s a car.

Al: Oh, there it is.

Joe: That is a piece of crap.

Al: Oh, that’s like a little one.

Joe: Oh, that’s like something you’d see Monty Python drive.

Al: That’s right.

Joe: “I bought cheap to use when my wife is at work and the kids are at school. I work from home.” all right. So let’s see. So he’s got some debt that’s stressing him out.

Al: Yep.

Joe: The wife’s got $130,000 pension when she retires-

Al: Yep …

Joe: at 57, so she must be, like, a school administrator. She doesn’t have Social Security, but she’s gonna receive the spousal benefit when he turns 65.

They wanna spend $200,000 after tax. Yep. So they need $70,000 from the portfolio when, he retires at age 65?

Al: Correct.

Joe: And he’s 57. And that- She’s 53.

Al: And that’s… Yeah, and I think if she retires and he’s still working, I ran those numbers, if they wanna spend at that point, with inflation, they’ll be spending 225,000.

if wife makes 20,000, husband makes, I don’t know what, she just, the, he said combined. I’m as- I’m, I just guessed 100, the husband makes about 60 and the pension’s 130, shortfall’s 15,000. They’ll have 1.2 million at that point with their current savings. Yeah, it ju- it works just fine. And then when he retires, most but not all of his income would be replaced by Social Security.

So yeah, n- the numbers work just fine, but I get the debt.

Joe: What’s the strategy around the debt?

Al: Yeah, that’s a good question. would you kinda soften up the retirement contributions and pay off more debt? me personally, I would. I would, do the contribution to the match, for sure, but then after that, I would start using money to pay down the debt ’cause I, yeah, that’s a lot of debt to take into retirement, I think.

That’s probably what I would do.

Joe: So you got a $300,000 mortgage.

Al: I’m, yeah, I don’t worry about that. It’s the-

Joe: You got $200,000 in student loan debt.

Al: Yeah, that plus the credit cards.

Joe: And credit card debt is how much?

Al: 70 grand.

Joe: Yeah. But he’s doing the, the balance transfer dance to get to 0% interest rate on that.

I know.

Al: Yeah, I, that’s, as long as it’s available.

Joe: I could see why the debt would stress him out, because it’s stressing me out just looking at it.

Al: Yeah, me too.

Joe: the problem is I think he’s- He’s used to doing the dance

So he’s gonna, you know, he’s shifting the cards around and-

Al: Yep

Joe: I would like to know what the balance of the credit cards were last year.

Was it s- 70,000, 65,000? Are they going down? Are they staying the same?

Al: Well, he says, “We’re currently paying down total debt at about 5,000 per year.”

Joe: Okay. So what- Total debt. So is that- But- That’s not including

Al: the- Yeah … mortgage … the mortgage. that’s probably just the credit card debt that got-

Joe: Credit card and student loan?

Or- Yeah … the student loan he’s racking up because he’s paying for the kids- Correct … right now.

Al: Student loan hasn’t come up yet.

Joe: Yeah. So the student loan’s after- Yeah … all of that is done because the kids are 17 and 15 or-

Al: I think they’re-

Joe: … or 19 and 16 …

Al: basically using the income to fully fund retirement accounts, which is good.

Joe: But is the credit card debt going up, down, or is it staying neutral?

Al: Okay.

Joe: Got it. Is kind of what I’m thinking. If it’s staying neutral-

Al: Yep …

Joe: I wouldn’t change anything. Y- I would keep doing what he’s doing because as soon as you stop putting money into the retirement accounts and you pay down the debt- and all of a sudden that credit card debt is not 70, it’s 30-

Al: Yep …

Joe: you know what? I bet that credit card debt goes back to 70 pretty quick.

Al: Well, you, you-

Joe: ‘Cause another thing happens, another- yeah … particular’s, and then, hey, we have some room. And, you know, I know this dance that I can play with the credit card.

Al: Yeah, I’ve done it my whole life.

Joe: if I’ve done it my whole life. But if I’m feeling a certain stress level at 70 I’m not probably gonna go higher than 70.

Al: Yeah.

Joe: But if it’s 40 or 50, I’m gonna be like, “You know what? This stress level’s not that bad. I could go back to 70 ’cause I al- already know what that feels like.”

Al: I,

can handle it.

Joe: And then but now that the, the credit card debt is back up to 70 and I’ve reduced my overall savings, now he’s in a lose-lose.

Al: Yeah. I agree. That’s a good point.

Joe: So I, don’t know how disciplined he is wh- when you’re looking at shifting this money because I can’t tell you… Like, let’s say, I’m- we’ve seen couples like this all the time.

It’s like, all right, well, here, we can kind of organize the debt a little bit. When interest rates were low, maybe d- do a HELOC, combine, get rid of the credit card debt. You got this ancillary, these loans, that, blah, blah, blah, you know, and it reduces your payment by $2,000 a month. You take the $2,000 extra a month that you freed up by consolidating the debt and you throw it against the debt to pay it down in X amount of years.

But what do most people do with that extra $2,000 a month?

Al: Yeah. Well, they spend it.

Joe: Well, they spend it.

Al: Yeah. No, you have to be disciplined.

Joe: Yeah, so that’s the, the- That, so- … that’s the only issue because he’s already disciplined enough by saving. I mean, they got a million dollars roughly saved in retirement accounts- which is a ton of money. Yep. And if they continue the savings as they are, they’re going to have, plenty of assets. They- she’s got a $130,000 pension. I mean, they’re gonna be fine.

Al: Yeah, they’re gonna be fine. So h- here’s why I don’t think they’re gonna do that, because he’s stressed, and he knows he’s gonna retire in eight years, and he- So

Joe: you have faith-

Al: I have f-

in- I have-

Joe: … Monty Python.

Al: I’ve, I, have faith that he’s, he doesn’t wanna feel this stress in retirement. but you do bring up a good point. But that’s what I would do, ’cause I

Joe: Well, well, Big Al. You- you’re Big Al.

Al: What would you do?

Joe: I would do- I, I would pay off that debt.

Al: Yeah, same thing. That’s what I just said.

Joe: Yep.

Al: But no, I get it. You bring up a super good point.

Joe: Yeah. Well, you and I are in the financial business.

Al: I know, we kinda get this stuff and live by it. Yeah. Or try

Andi: to. Helpfully by the fact that they’re actually writing in, that means that they wanna be serious and disciplined about this.

Joe: Well-

Al: Yeah. Yep.

But yeah, I mean, you’d always, fund your retirement to the match, for sure, right?

Joe: I love their savings. I… And if they can keep the debt in control, then it’s like, all right, now you have options. You got 1.2, you gotta kinda check, check on it there to- start moving the money around a little bit later in life.

At least wait until 59 and a half. I wouldn’t do it, y- you know, I like… He’s already talking about Roth conversions and this- Yeah …

Al: that, whatever. That’s l- less important.

Joe: Yeah, way less important than- … looking at, all right, here, you wanna spend a couple of hundred thousand dollars a year. At two, at $130,000 of income, he needs to pull 70.

he’s not g- the, the RMDs are not gonna kill him. It’s not gonna blow him up into a higher bracket.

Al: No, ’cause

Joe: he’s- ‘Cause he, he’s- Oh, he’s- … gonna use that kit …

Al: yeah. He’ll, you’re right, with the 130.

Joe: Yep. So, and then your Social Security on top of that, he’s probably gonna be stuck in that 22, 24 tax range.

I would be k- taking dollars from the retirement accounts at 59, and then probably getting rid of the debt that way, so he doesn’t have to pay state tax on it versus- So- … when converting …

Al: so would you build it up and do a 50K distribution at 59 and a half to pay it off?

Joe: Yeah. I don’t… Well, that doesn’t make a lot of sense either.

you’re just

Al: p- I wouldn’t do that. I’d just pay as you, pay currently. but I get your point, and it’s a valid point. It, all depends upon the discipline.

Joe: Yep.

Al: but if he decides to pay off the debt and reduce his retirement, snowball or avalanche?

Joe: Ooh, snowball or avalanche? Well, av- I like the snowball approach.

Andi: Smallest balance first Snowball is where you pay off the smallest ones first, right?

Al: Yeah.

Joe: Yeah.

Al: Get them off the- And then you get- Off the books.

Joe: Yeah,

Al: you

Joe: get-

Al: Just, what you’re talking about, that you get the emotion helping you.

Joe: I, yeah, money’s emotional.

Al: It is. I know. Yeah.

Joe: we’re all about

Andi: the rollercoaster.

And then how does the avalanche work?

Joe: Avalanche is that you pay the highest interest rate first.

Al: Correct. yeah. So yeah, snowball you pay the lowest balance to get, to gain confidence, and the avalanche you pay the highest interest rate first, even if it’s a high balance card.

Andi: So you could do a snowball avalanche.

You could pay off the smallest ones and then switch to the most highest interest rate.

Al: You can do anything you want.

Joe: Yeah. That’s a-

Al: I mean, you and I have talked about this. If for me, I’d do avalanche ’cause I understand-

Joe: Math …

Al: math.

Joe: The interest rate is high. But- But, I get- But what if, it’s a large balance and you see all these, you know, you’re getting these bills in the mail every-

Al: Yeah

Joe: month. It- I would like to get less mail.

Al: Yes.

Joe: I- I’m going snowball.

Al: I don’t disagree with that. I’m going- Yeah. If that feels better.

Joe: Yeah, it does. Hey, not, so yeah, let’s say he’s got six credit cards, and he’s got this loan, he’s got that loan. One could be 3,000, one’s 10,000, one’s 15,000, then your mortgage is the 300,000.

Al: Yeah.

Joe: You just go up with the smallest balance, even though let’s say it’s 0%.

Al: Yeah.

Joe: But- Pay it off …

Al: by the way, I checked with our friend Dave Ramsey.

Joe: Yeah?

Al: He-

Joe: he’s your friend?

Al: He’s our friend.

Joe: Is he? Okay.

Al: he likes snowball.

Joe: He likes the snowball, too.

Al: Yep. Yep.

Joe: All righty.

Al: Yep.

Joe: Okay.

Al: You’re in good company.

Andi: He also says you can spend 8% per year in retirement.

Joe: Yeah, and then the market-

Al: Well, yeah … will make 2%. And you’ll get at least- Annually … 12% on having growth funds. Yeah. Yeah, forget that part.

Joe: Okay.

Andi: Social Security has found its way into every spitball today, because when you claim benefits can change how much income you collect for the rest of your life, and for married couples, what your survivor gets too. Our free Social Security Handbook walks you through how your benefit is calculated, claiming early versus late, working while you collect benefits, whether you can change your mind, spousal and survivor benefits, how Social Security gets taxed, and advanced filing strategies. The handbook also covers the Social Security Fairness Act, which eliminated the rules that used to reduce or wipe out benefits for people with pensions. Click or tap the link in the episode description and download the Social Security Handbook, free. Choose “podcast” in the “how did you hear about us” dropdown, and tell a friend about the show and all the free financial resources.

Too Much Roth? When to Switch Back to a Pre-Tax 401(k) (Roger Thornhill/George Kaplan, CA)

Joe: We got George Kaplan and Roger Thor- Thornhill-

Andi: Do you know those names?

Joe: No idea. Absolutely not.

Andi: Okay. Cary Grant starred in the movie, f- North by Northwest. It’s an Alfred Hitchcock movie in 1959, where advertising executive Roger Thornhill is mistaken for a government agent named George Kaplan, and he’s played by Cary Grant.

Joe: okay. “I’m writing in with a few questions about retirement. Don’t drink much alcohol, but I, but if I do I like a little red wine because you make me feel so fine and you keep me rockin’ all the time.”

Andi: Red, red wine.

Joe: Oh. Yes. Joe should know where that came from. Yeah.

Al: That, now that one I did know.

Joe: Yeah.

Al: How about that? That’s surprising.

Joe: “I’m 57-

Andi: Do you know the band?

Al: Yeah, UB40.

Andi: Yes.

Joe: Yeah. Oh, look at Big Al. Look at the big brain on Big Al.

Al: that’s my first thing in many episodes that I-

Joe: Yes. “I’m 57, single, no kids, live in the high-tax California. I was planning to retire and leave California to a lower stat, tax state at the end of 2032, but would like to move, up, move that up to 2029.

I have $1.3 million in a brokerage account, $60,000 in emergency funds, $80,000 in an HSA. Roth IRA and 401(k) accounts are $1.7 million, and a small amount in traditional in current employer with a match of about 75 grand. I’m currently maxing out 401(k) Roth, including catch-up and backdoor Roth with catch-up.”

All right. “Would like to have a minimum of $2 million in a Roth and $4 million overall. that’s the number I need to retire. I make $180,000 a year. Do not spend much, but wanna spend more in retirement of at least around $80,000 a year. I’ll be eligible for pensions of $42,000 a year and will not be eligible to collect that until I’m age 65.

Two questions I have regarding this retirement. First one, should I switch to traditional 401(k) over the next few years to lower my taxes? Putting funds, investing in fixed income part of the 401(k) since that would grow much, would not grow much. Currently only 12% of my total retirement is in fixed income.”

All right. Fixed companies comprise 10% of the total portfolio, then using the traditional money to at least partially carry me through until my pension start at age 65. This guy’s pretty smart

Al: He is smart, yep

Joe: T is a smart dude, this guy. second, question is about Social Security. “I was planning to wait until 70 when I would get around $57,000 annually.

However, recent proposals to address Social Security shortfalls proposed limiting single persons to a maximum of $50,000 annually. While no one knows for sure, this seems like a proposal Congress would jump on, especially taking from those of us who have saved in retirement accounts. If they do, then filing early seems like a better option, unless I’m missing something.

What are your thoughts? Sincerely, Roger Thornhill.” Andi’s note, Cary Grant character from North by Northwest, 1959 okay. Yes, I like where this guy’s going. He wants to retire in how many years?

Al: In three years.

Joe: Yep. And, and- And he’s only got 10% of his portfolio in fixed income.

Al: Yeah, that’s what he says.

Joe: So he knows that he needs probably a little bit more fixed income in the portfolio to stabilize the portfolio as he approaches retirement.

Al: Sure.

Joe: He also knows that fixed income has a lower expected return than equities.

Al: Yep.

Joe: So he makes $180,000 as a single taxpayer, so that puts him in the 22, 24% tax bracket. M- he’s got a lot of money in Roth IRAs. He has very little of the total balance of his accounts in traditional. So does it make sense for him to go traditional, invest in fixed income because he knows that, “Hey, it’s, I need fixed income anyway.

It’s gonna s- stabilize the portfolio, but it’s also, it has a lower expected return than equities. Then I’m gonna take that money out in lower tax brackets to bridge the gap to, my pensions and Social Security.”

Al: Yep.

Joe: Phenomenal idea. Yeah. Right on. 100%.

Al: Yeah, agreed. Yeah, agreed. I would, switch to traditional since there’s hardly any there.

Get the tax deduction. If you wanna convert later, you can, but you don’t need to. There’s so little in traditional. Well, he

Joe: needs, he needs to pull somewhere to live off of.

Al: Yeah,

Joe: And so he’s gonna pull that money to live off of in low brackets.

Al: exactly.

Joe: So I don’t think he even needs to convert anything.

He lives off of the money that he saves over the next three years in the traditional, plus the 75 grand that he has there.

Al: yeah.

Joe: That money would never touch anything higher than the 12% tax bracket. Th-

Al: yeah, I’m right with you. Agreed. Second question. What about Social Security?

Joe: he’s o- how old is he?

60?

Al: He is 57. He’ll retire at 60.

Joe: Yeah, I would wait till 62 and then reevaluate. A lot of things can change over the next five years.

Al: Yeah. My comment on that-

Joe: Now, it’s like he can’t elect right now to take it.

Al: No, he can’t.

Joe: He’s gotta wait till 62. Should he take it early? Should he take it at age 70? If he’s running his spreadsheets, I think he reevaluate at 62 to see, you know, w- where things are at.

Al: Yeah, I’m comput-

Joe: I’m getting- But I’m getting in on that right now …

Al: n- well, doing a little math, I’m getting at age 60, a 2.2% distribution rate. So, without Social Security, Joe. So he can wait. But I think, I, w- maybe I would make this comment. I would never make, do a strategy based upon a tax proposal because a lot of times they don’t happen.

Wait till it, it becomes reality and, if it does, then, you know, then, go ahead and make some changes if you need to. But, yeah, I wouldn’t make a, I wouldn’t do it. Plus, as you say, Joe, he can’t do anything anyway. So, just wait and see how this- We can

Joe: talk about it but, I mean, it’s just a waste of-

Al: I- yeah, there’s no point ’cause we don’t know what’s gonna happen.

So, anyway. Yeah. But he’s in a great spot, and I agree, he’s, very clever putting this together. Now, here’s an example of someone with… He’ll end up with almost $4 million, Joe. The other one, person that we just talked about had 3 million. Now, he’s spending 80 and the other person’s spending 200,000.

So, which do you think works out better? It really comes down to that relationship between the assets that you have and fixed income and spending to figure out whether this is gonna work or not. It’s, not that tricky when you think of it that way.

Joe: Right. Cool.

Andi: You sure you don’t have time for one more?

Okay. The next one is very closely related.

Joe: Well, all right. And then it’s three pages long, Andi.

Al: No, that’s too long. We’re done.

Andi: We can skip it. We can skip it.

Al: We’ll do it next time.

Joe: All right. Okay. that’s it for us, folks. Keep the questions coming. We’ll answer them as soon as we get to them.

We’re probably s- eight months behind, but- … we will definitely get there. show’s called Your Money, Your Wealth. We’ll see you next time.

Outro: Next Week on the YMYW Podcast

Andi: We’ve got Vision Quest, Monty Python and Life of Brian trivia, and North by Northwest in the Derails at the end of the episode today, so stick around. Next week on YMYW, Henry in Houston’s custodian won’t let him do what he wants with the tax withholding on his Roth conversion. Can Roy Hinkley ditch his quarterly estimated tax checks with one IRA withdrawal, and where does his name come from, by the way? Should the High Desert Jarhead pay his Roth conversion tax with Roth money? Can $2.8 million cover $150,000 a year in retirement spending for Bob Wills, starting at age 48? And finally, Pumpkin and Honey Bunny have three Roths for three kids. How do they even out their inheritances? Join us in episode 609 next week and find out.

Now remember, the numbers and goals you hear in YMYW spitballs are unique to each emailer. Yours are entirely different. For a plan built around your life, meet with the experienced professionals on Joe and Big Al’s team at Pure Financial Advisors for a free financial assessment. That’s right, it costs the same as a spitball: nothing. And as you know, the YMYW inbox is very full. If you request an assessment now, you’ll likely be sitting down with someone in time for end-of-year tax planning – and long before your email makes it onto the podcast. Pure has offices from California to Tennessee, or you can meet online from the comfort of your own home, no matter where you are. The plan they build is tailored to your needs and your goals. And with just a few weeks left in the year, there’s still time to talk through those year-end moves like Roth conversions, which have to be done by December 31st. Click or tap the free assessment link in the episode description, or call 888-994-6257 to schedule yours.

Pure Financial Advisors is a registered investment advisor. This show does not intend to provide personalized investment advice through this podcast and does not represent that the securities or services discussed are suitable for any investor. As rules and regulations change, podcast content may become outdated. Investors are advised not to rely on any information contained in the podcast in the process of making a full and informed investment decision.

The Derails: Vision Quest, Monty Python trivia, and North by Northwest

Andi: From the movie Vision Quest from 1985.

Joe: Oh, that’s a great movie. That’s the wrestler.

Andi: Yes.

Andi: Matthew Modine

Joe: … Matthew Modine. Yeah. Who’s the la- who was the girl in that one?

Andi: Linda Fiorrentir- Fiorentino.

Joe: Never seen her in another movie.

Al: That was a one and done, huh?

Joe: Yeah, Matthew Me- D- yeah. The guy that he wrestled was, like, that big ass… What was his nickname? Like, The Bull? he’d walk up the stadium stairs with a big ass log on.

Al: Oh, the refrigerator? What? You’re talking about that guy?

Joe: No, the guy that he wrestled-

Andi: Shute

Joe: … in the movie.

Al: Oh, in the movie,

Joe: okay.

In the movie. Yeah.

Al: Is it Shute?

Joe: Oh, Shute. Yeah. Yeah. Shute. He was a badass.

Al: Got it. Okay.

Joe: All right. All right. there you go. It’s a little re-watchable. I think everyone should,

Andi: I’ve never

seen it.

I’m gonna watch it

Joe: Yeah. There’s a couple good scenes.

Al: Couple good scenes.

Joe: Yeah.

Al: So it’s worth the two hours?

Joe: I think so. Okay. I would highly recommend- All right … Vision Quest.

Al: Okay.

Joe: Never watched anything Monty Python.

Andi: What?

Joe: No.

Andi: Oh, my goodness. Okay.

Joe: I think I’m too young for Monty Python.

Al: Yeah, you missed it.

Joe: Missed my- I’m,

Al: I’m almost too young for it.

Joe: I missed my window. What was, what was Monty Python? What was the funniest thing?

Andi: They were-

Joe: The funniest thing, that’s a hard question.

Or, oh, what’s the most famous thing? Life of Brian?

Andi: their movies were a big deal. yeah, The Life of Brian, the Monty Python and the Holy Grail. One of them was actually funded by George Harrison because he thought that Monty Python was so funny that they needed the funding, and so he actually paid for one of their movies to be made.

Joe: And George Harrison is one of The Beatles?

Andi: Yes.

Al: Yep.

Joe: Got it.

Andi: Glad you know that one.

Al: Yeah, you d- you do know that one.

Joe: So Monty Python is British.

Andi: Yes, correct.

Joe: Okay.

Al: I will say, and I, have seen it. I haven’t watched it a lot, but the, when I get together with people that are about four or five years older than me, that’s all they talk about.

Ah. See, I’m too young.

Joe: It’s like, is that the Pink Panther?

Andi: See, and I’m… is what?

Joe: Is that the Pink Panther? Who, like, who played Monty Python? What’s the actor?

Andi: There is no a single actor that is Monty Python. It wasn’t a person, it was a comedic troupe. Oh. So Eric Idle, who else was in it?

Al: John Cleese.

Yeah,

Andi: John Cleese. John Cleese, yes. Yeah. the character- So he’s Monty Python, John Cleese … of Brian Cohen was played by G- Graham Chapman. There is no single person named Monty Python, no.

Joe: Got it. All right. See? They- We’re learning all sorts of things.

Al: It’s like- So, so Andi, may- maybe your parents were the right age and you were watching it as a kid, ’cause they were-

Andi: No, I don’t think I was.

But the, I just, it’s so- You know, that- that’s, they’re classic. And so my, actually my first husband was a big fan of Monty Python, so I watched a lot of it with him.

Al: They are, they are classic. Well, I will say-

Andi: Yeah, absolutely

Al: … this, this group of friends that I’m talking about, before our next get-together, I’m gonna watch about 10 of them, ’cause it’s like-

what are you talking about?

Joe: Yeah. Not Monty Python.

Andi: It definitely requires a certain sense of humor. In this, this particular movie, The Life of Brian, the character of Brian is born in the manger next door to Jesus’s, so they keep getting him confused with Jesus. That’s the whole point of the entire movie.

I love it. So, and the actress that plays Judith Iscariot in the movie, apparently later in her career ended up becoming mayor of a town in Wales, where they had originally banned the movie- Oh … in 1979 when it came out because of blasphemy. When she became mayor, she actually made it so that it was no longer illegal to watch her movie in their town.

Al: Isn’t that something? Okay. Yeah. Wow.

Joe: Wow. Trivia.

Al: Getting kind of excited now. This is something I could watch.

Joe: Oh- So- … so he’s both people.

Got it. Got it. So he’s a dual agent here.

Andi: Exactly.

Al: Got it. Yeah.

Joe: So, s- so he’s mistaken… what what did you say? He’s an insurance agent that was mistaken to be a, an-

Andi: He’s an advertising executive that’s mistaken for a government agent. Ah. So Roger Thornhill is the ad executive. He’s mistaken for George Kaplan, who’s the government agent, and I believe Roger Thornhill actually gets murdered in the movie.

Not to, like, s- give you a- Spoiler … spoiler alert for a 1959- Spoiler … movie, North by Northwest.

Al: Yep. I remember seeing- Well- I remember seeing that. I, ha- that, I don’t have much of a memory of it, ’cause I don’t with movies, but I remember really enjoying it. I’ll put it that way.

Andi: It’s Hitchcock. I mean-

Yeah,

you can’t go wrong if you’re into that kind of thing.

Al: Yeah,

Joe: Okay. I’m writing… I- is there Halloween in Australia?

Andi: Oh, yeah. Absolutely.

Joe: Same day?

Andi: It’s, not kind of as… Well, it’s the day before for us because it’s always tomorrow.

Joe: Yeah.

Andi: But yeah, so, so it’s October 31st. It’s not as big a deal for kids to trick or treat as it is in the States, but that is becoming more of a thing here.

But, yeah, adults definitely dress up and have parties and stuff. I, went to a Halloween party, yeah.

Joe: What’d you dress up as?

Andi: As a warrior. I wore a corset-

Joe: Oh, a warrior

Andi: … I carried my spear and had a big helmet and the whole bit, yeah.

Joe: Oh. Have you ever seen the movie The Warriors?

Andi: No.

Joe: Oh. Big Al?

Al: No.

Joe: It’s a classic.

It’s so good.

Al: I’m sure it is.

Joe: All right.

_______

IMPORTANT DISCLOSURES:

Pure Financial Advisors is a registered investment advisor. This show does not intend to provide personalized investment advice through this podcast and does not represent that the securities or services discussed are suitable for any investor. As rules and regulations change, podcast content may become outdated. Investors are advised not to rely on any information contained in the podcast in the process of making a full and informed investment decision.

• Investment Advisory and Financial Planning Services are offered through Pure Financial Advisors, LLC, a Registered Investment Advisor.

• Pure Financial Advisors LLC does not offer tax or legal advice. Consult with your tax advisor or attorney regarding specific situations.

• Opinions expressed are not intended as investment advice or to predict future performance.

• Past performance does not guarantee future results.

• Investing involves risk including the potential loss of principal. No investment strategy can guarantee a profit or protect against loss in periods of declining values.

• All information is believed to be from reliable sources; however, we make no representation as to its completeness or accuracy. As rules and regulations change, content may become outdated.

• Intended for educational purposes only and are not intended as individualized advice or a guarantee that you will achieve a desired result. Before implementing any strategies discussed you should consult your tax and financial advisors.

CFP® – The CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER® certification is by the CFP Board of Standards, Inc. To attain the right to use the CFP® mark, an individual must satisfactorily fulfill education, experience and ethics requirements as well as pass a comprehensive exam. 30 hours of continuing education is required every 2 years to maintain the certification.

AIF® – Accredited Investment Fiduciary designation is administered by the Center for Fiduciary Studies fi360. To receive the AIF Designation, an individual must meet prerequisite criteria, complete a training program, and pass a comprehensive examination. Six hours of continuing education is required annually to maintain the designation.

CPA – Certified Public Accountant is a license set by the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants and administered by the National Association of State Boards of Accountancy. Eligibility to sit for the Uniform CPA Exam is determined by individual State Boards of Accountancy. Typically, the requirement is a U.S. bachelor’s degree which includes a minimum number of qualifying credit hours in accounting and business administration with an additional one-year study. All CPA candidates must pass the Uniform CPA Exam to qualify for a CPA certificate and license (i.e., permit to practice) to practice public accounting. CPAs are required to take continuing education courses to renew their license, and most states require CPAs to complete an ethics course during every renewal period. Pure Financial CPAs do not act as your accountant or provide tax services unless specifically stated.