Pure’s guest speaker, Dr. Katy Votava, president and founder of GoodCare.com, walks attendees through the essentials and answers top Medicare questions.
Outline
- 00:00 – The Overspending Problem
- 01:30 – Medicare Parts Explained
- 03:16 – Enrollment Periods
- 05:09 – Working Past 65 & COBRA
- 07:58 – Original Medicare vs. Advantage
- 14:50 – What Medicare Doesn’t Cover
- 19:23 – Shopping for Plans
- 26:20 – Audience Q&A
- 36:10 – Income-Based Premiums
- 41:59 – Penalties & Action Steps
Transcription:
(NOTE: Transcriptions are an approximation and may not be entirely correct)
Kathryn Bowie, CFP®: Welcome to our Medicare webinar. We are so appreciative of you joining us. I would like to introduce Dr. Katie Votava. She is the author of the bestselling book called Making the Most of Medicare: A Guide for Baby Boomers.
Dr. Katy Votava: Thank you for having me. It’s my pleasure to be here to help your clients and folks to figure out Medicare best as possible.
Now, one thing I think is important to know, and most people don’t know this, that 90 to 95% of people on Medicare are overspending, and that’s really a shame. And why does that happen? It’s because people don’t understand their options. They don’t shop on time, and therefore, they don’t get the best plan for themselves or their family members.
But that doesn’t have to happen. When you plan ahead and do your shopping properly, and we’re gonna talk about that, you will be able to avoid that problem because it is ex- since things are already so expensive, and then to spend more than you need to, we’re gonna help you figure out how not to do that.
Now, I like to quote a famous poet here, Mick Jagger, “You can’t always get what you want, but if you try sometimes, you can get what you need.” And I think it’s important to remember that with Medicare because I think sometimes the general perception is it’s so confusing and you don’t know what to do, and you don’t know where to go.
But honestly, if you put a little effort in, and we’re gonna focus on a couple of simple things. I will talk about some things that are a little more complicated, but talk about simple strategies so you can do the best for yourself, particularly this time of year when shopping for health coverage.
Medicare has three main parts, multiple ways to put it together. Now, Part A is the hospital part. That’s the part we’ve all prepaid for with our payroll taxes. A lot of people don’t realize that we’ve only prepaid for that Part A portion, and there still are co-payments in Part A. And then there is Part B.
B as in benefit. It’s a big benefit anymore. When it went into law in 1965, it was a small thing. There wasn’t much that was done outpatient other than seeing your doctor or getting a few lab tests done. But now we have outpatient surgery, MRI, cancer treatments, all kinds of things. So Medicare Part B, B as in benefit, is a big benefit, and it is something we pay for.
We have not prepaid for Medicare Part B, any of the outpatient services, and that does come as a surprise to people, and we’re gonna talk about that cost and how you’re gonna work with your financial advisor to not pay more than you need to, at least. Then there’s Part D. Now, I’ve pick- I’ve skipped over Part C, and I’ll tell you why in a moment.
Part D, prescription drug coverage. It’s only about 12 years old. For the longest time, we had no prescription drug coverage in Medicare, but as we have more and more medications for people, we really needed that coverage. So that was added, eh, around 2014 Now Part C, it’s called Part C, but it’s really not a separate part of Medicare.
It puts together Parts A, hospital, Part B, outpatient, and usually Part D into something called a Medicare Advantage plan. You’ve probably heard that term extensively. Medicare Advantage and Part C are the same thing, so not a separate part but a different way to put Medicare together. So that’s one way to put Medicare together.
So let’s talk a little bit about timing. In particular, we are looking at the initial enrollment period for everybody who’s going into Medicare when they’re new and turning 65, that is important. Three months before you’re 65, three months after you’re 65. That’s if you wanna go into Medicare. If you’re working, we’ll talk about that, you may not want to go into any part of Medicare when you are 65 years old, and I’ll tell you some reason why.
But right now we are in the, what’s called the annual enrollment period. Down here one, two, three, four. Down here. It’s October 15th through December 7th. That happens every year, and everyone who’s in Medicare can reevaluate either a prescription drug plan or their Medicare Advantage plan and see what’s gonna be available next year.
One of the biggest mistakes is to just think, “Well, what I have this year is okay, and next year I’m not gonna… there’s gonna be nothing different.” Well, that’s an assumption. It can really give you a real problem. So this is the time of year, whether it’s for yourself or a family member, to take a look at what the options are.
There are other enrollment periods that at times come into play, special enrollment periods which do come into play when people work beyond the age of 65. Because you have to get into Medicare in your initial enrollment period three months before, three months after 65 unless you have appropriate employer coverage that will cover you.
And that is something that everyone can look at in their en… plans come up every year to say, “Okay, I’m working. Does my plan-” pass muster for Medicare. And what I mean by that is does it meet the standards or exceed the standards for Medicare. So you have to decide that around the 65th birth month of whether you’re getting in now or whether you’re gonna wait.
Another thing to think about, particularly if you are working, is that you don’t want to even sign up for any Par- It used to be we’d tell people, “Get into Medicare Part A ’cause it’s free. Sign up for B later.” I no longer say that, particularly if people have health savings accounts, because once you have any part of Medicare, including Part A, you can’t contribute any new dollars into a health savings account, which say if you work another three or four years, that’s a lot of money that you would be able to contribute tax-free.
So do not go into Medicare, even Part A, when you’re 65 unless you are going to go into Medicare in total So I mentioned, what if you’re working at 65? Many people are. If you’re with a company that has 20 or more employees, so if it’s a really small business, you’re still better off to go into Medicare because the rules are, and this is the Medicare rule, that if it’s 20 or more employees, the employer coverage pays first and you don’t need Medicare.
If it’s fewer, then Medicare has to pay first and you really need, if you delay Part A and B, you’re gonna be in trouble. And I’ve seen people who didn’t realize this and then they were in their company plan for a while, even a small business, but then they get sick and then the bills get big and then the plan says, “Oh, wait a minute, you’re supposed to be in Part A and Part B.”
So just know that it’s 20 or, 20 or more employees, your employer coverage covers for you. If not, if it’s smaller, get into Medicare. The other thing is sometimes we do find people whose coverage even in a bigger plan isn’t that great. So if you have employer coverage and it’s really not working that well for you, it’s fine to go ahead and reevaluate that and say, “Maybe I would be better off in Medicare.”
And you don’t have to stay in your employer plan if you don’t want to. There’s another thing we’re gonna talk about in a minute is that something about COBRA. You’ve ever heard this term COBRA, continuous coverage after a person leaves work? Well, one thing, COBRA and Medicare don’t mix at all.
So if you think, and I’ve known of people who have negotiated, let’s say, a severance and they’ve said, “Oh, hey, this is great. I’m gonna get my COBRA coverage.” COBRA is the coverage that you had through your employer. You pay the full price plus 2%. But people negotiate for that sometimes to be covered in full for themselves or their family.
Okay, sounds good till if you ha- are Medicare eligible or become Medicare eligible while you’re on COBRA, COBRA has to kick you off. So just be careful, particularly if you’re negotiating severances, that you don’t negotiate a benefit that you really can’t use and you won’t know until you’ve already left the plan.
But it is something you can know ahead of time and those rules between Medicare and COBRA I find trip people up quite a bit So Medicare, we mentioned Medicare Advantage, which we see on the right-hand side, and then there’s something called Original Medicare. I think people s- kind of hear this term anymore.
The idea with this slide is that there are two main ways to put Medicare together for yourself, multiple choices within, but two main ways. One on the left-hand side you’ll see is Original Medicare. That’s Part A and B, which you apply for through the Social Security Administration. You don’t apply through Medicare, you apply through the Social Security Administration.
Why? Because you gain the privilege of having Social Security Medicare once you have acquired your 40 work quarters under Social Security. So you apply through Social Security Parts A and B, and then I suggest you get a Part D. It’s not required, but if you don’t have a D plan and later down the road you want to sign up for one, you’ll be in a penalty position for the rest of your life.
And I’ve known of people say, “Well, I don’t take any medications, I don’t need it.” Well, if you get sick and you need expensive medications, you will have a delay. Besides the fact you’ll have a penalty, you will have a delay from the time you apply till your coverage is covering you. So that’s three parts so far that included, and then there’s something called a Medigap plan.
You may have heard of this, you may not have heard of it. It’s, some people use the term supplemental. I think the term supplemental is confusing because some people refer to a Medigap plan as supplemental, some people refer to a Medicare Advantage plan as supplemental. So that’s what I’m saying about lingo.
I don’t use the term supplemental. I use the actual names. So a Medigap plan pays for the co-payments and co-insurance in Medicare A and B, not the drug part, but in Medicare A and B, because even though A and B cover a lot, they only cover 80% of… And that’s a general rule of thumb, and the consumer has to pay 20%, and 20% of a big bill is a lot of money.
So you can get a Medigap plan, and we’ll talk a little bit more about, there are 11 styles of them and how to shop for them. So that’s one way to do it, is put all your coverage together in one, one grouping. Or you can get a Medicare Advantage plan, a Part C plan. It combines A and B, and usually D. And we’ll see there’s some big differences of how those plans work and how the costs are.
Some people like the original Medicare, and we’ll talk about why. Some people like Medicare Advantage plans, and w- and we’ll talk about why that as well. So when we compare the two sides of the chart, here’s some of the major differences. If you have O- original Medicare and a Medigap plan, you can go to any doctor, any hospital, any provider anywhere in the United States.
That’s a lot of choice. That’s not true in Medicare Advantage. Medicare Advantage usually has networks, and more and more we see more plans that have what I’m calling exclusive networks, where you can’t go out of network without a big hoop to do. So be aware of that as being an issue with Medicare Advantage plan, whereas original Medicare and Medigap, you go anywhere you want to for care.
Original Medicare involves almost no referrals, whereas Medicare Advantage usually envir- involves referrals and prior authorizations. And for people, sometimes that’s a hassle. Sometimes more hassle than, than you want it to be, and particularly when you’re ill, that can get in the way of your care. The medical cost risk is different from one type of coverage to the other, and I’ve got a chart I’ll show you in a minute And most of the time if you have a original Medicare and a Medigap plan, I recommend you get a stand…
what’s called a standalone drug plan. But most Medicare Advantage plans have the D plan built into it. People like that because it’s one card, one type of insurance, whereas if you’re in original Medicare and Medigap and the D plan, you have three different cards. But what are the differences in costs and what you pay for?
Now, the original Medicare Part D and Medigap, the annual premium, and this is a national number, is over, it’s about $2,300. And of course, we’re not gonna have a Medigap premium on this side of the chart. The Part D is about $172, although frankly it’s a national number, but I think that’s a little cheap.
But if you are in Medicare Advantage, your whole top cost up until here is only $172. So people find Medicare Advantage predominantly attractive because the cost, monthly cost is low. It is low. But what you find out along the way is your out-of-pocket costs can really add up in Medicare Advantage, up to almost $10,000 a year in a Medicare Advantage plan.
Now, many plans have a little lower limit, more like $7,500, but it’s still a lot of co-payments and co-insurance are built into the plan. But if you have a Medigap G, and there are 11 styles of G, we’re not gonna go into them all today. I recommend G. G as in good. That will cover almost all of your out-of-pocket costs for when you go to the hospital, co-payments to see the doctor, MRIs and so on and so forth.
The only thing you pay is a Part B deductible, which is $292 in a year. Everybody in Part D, whether you get a standalone plan or a Medicare Advantage plan, the out-of-pocket cost limit this coming year, 2027, is $2,400 either way. But when you look at the total down here, the total what I’m calling cost exposure, while Medigap and original Medicare cost more on a monthly basis, your cost exposure is less.
You have kept your costs lower than if you were in a Medicare Advantage plan. Now, if people are real healthy, they may not have any high cost at all and they say, “Well, you know…” And that’s what I find in Medicare Advantage plans when people are in them and like them, they’re people who are pretty healthy, don’t need to go to the doctor much, don’t need much equipment and so on and so forth.
Once people have a lot of health problems, two things, it costs them more and you have a lot of rigmarole to get the care you need, or you can’t go where you want to go for care. So these are important things to think about before you enter into a plan because some plans you can change every year, but some of your choices really are not changeable every year.
So what doesn’t Medicare cover? It does not cover routine dental care. Now, I will tell you that very seldom do I see a dental insurance that you can buy yourself that’s worth buying. I’ll be perfectly honest with you. Once in a while we do, but if you are retiring from a company and they have a group dental and you can go under COBRA, that is a part of COBRA that could work for you because the best price is going to be a group plan.
So for 18 months, you could consider getting your employer participating in that. Beyond that, generally no, they’re not worth it in my opinion. The coverage limits are low, the costs are high. So what I do is I recommend that you talk to your dentist. Call the office before you go, tell them you don’t have insurance anymore and that you’re on Medicare and ask them for the best cash price and most of the time you’re gonna get a, a better price.
Now, if you… Medicare Advantage plans, some of them do cover routine dental cleaning and they do cover eyewear. And I’ll tell you what I think about all those extra benefits in Medicare Advantage. You gotta remember that- Health insurance is to protect aga- against the catastrophe. It’s not a discount buying club, and yet sometimes we treat it that way.
Medicare Advantage, you say, “Well, I can get my teeth cleaned, I can get some eye glasses,” and so on. Well, if your fundamental coverage doesn’t cover your doctors or your medications, then you haven’t done yourself any favors. So what I say is if you go into Medicare Advantage and want to, make sure it, the coverage is what you need, and we’ll talk about the two most important things in a minute for it to cover.
And then if it does cover your important things and it’s a bonus to get two cleanings a year, that’s great, but I would not pick a Medicare Advantage plan because I can get my teeth cleaned. Particularly then if you don’t have the hospitals you want, doctors you need, or medications, then you will be very upset about it.
Now, vision care. That term is, to me, it’s a misnomer. They talk about vision care. Well, original Medicare or in a Medicare Advantage plan, your eye care is covered by Medicare A and B. You have cataracts, you have glaucoma, you get pink eye, whatever it is, the medical portion is already covered under Medicare.
So when you see vision care, really what it is eyewear. And again, I haven’t seen a vision care plan worth buying in quite some time. Somebody sees one, great, show it to me. You know, I don’t have any stake in any of these plans one way or another. But basically it’s a benefit for discounts in eyewear.
Anymore, eyewear is a very competitive marketplace, and you can do just as well by shopping around for discounts on your eyewear. Now, again, if you are retiring from a company and they have a COBRA benefit for eyewear and it makes sense to you, go ahead and pick it up for 18 months. It will be a better price for you, but buying it personally, privately, no.
General, I haven’t seen one in a long time that I’ve recommended. Hearing aids. Hearing aids really are, have come down tremendously in price. Some Medicare Advantage plans cover not any hearing aid, but cover some hearing aids. So again, if that’s something that is helpful to you. But what I’ve seen over the counter more and more- They’re not exactly cheap, but they could be $200 for hearing aids as opposed to $6,000, which is what they used to be.
So the hearing, hearing aid market is much more competitive than it used to be. So just be aware that there are options out there. And maybe if you are approaching that need hearing aids, there are a lot of people into hearing aids that have kind of said, “Nah, not me.” Well, while you still have group coverage, check into it and have a good hearing evaluation.
That will really be worth it to you. But in terms of ear care, ear, nose, and throat care, that is all covered under your medical portion. Now, one of the other things that is not covered at all under Medicare and it surprises people is long-term care. Medicare does not cover long-term care, whether it’s in home care or in assisted living or in a skilled nursing facility.
And you will still have to pay your Medicare premiums and all of that on top of long-term care costs. So that’s something important for you to have a conversation with your financial advisor about how are you gonna cover that cost risk, because that is a cost risk. All right. So like I said, we are in annual enrollment right now, so now is the time to look for plans for January 1st next year and see what’s gonna be better for you or your family member.
Now, a lot of times people feel like this, this poor person hitting their head, like, oh my gosh. Well, we’re gonna give you some stuff that’ll make it easier for you, I think, to pursue what you need. And one thing I say to people, and a lot of people don’t believe it, is if you can shop online for shoes, you can shop for Medicare or any other insurance.
The reason why is that we’re gonna focus on two things, and that’s the two most important things Are your care providers in network? That’s your doctors, hospitals, physical therapists, medical equipment supply. Now, some people don’t need medical equipment supply, but people who already have a lot of health problems, they know the folks they like to work with.
And what I do say to people is, “If you’re really healthy, that’s great.” And you say, “Well, I don’t know who I’d go to for a hospital.” What I recommend is that you look at the best hospitals in your area and make sure that the coverage you have will cover those hospitals if you were to need an emergency or something like that.
But your care providers need to be in network and covered. And are your medications covered? The medication coverage in Part D is very general, and there are probably in every ZIP code there are about 20 or more plans, but they’re not all the same. They don’t all cover the same things at all, and even if they cover one medication in one plan could be covered economically in one plan, but not very well in another.
So it really is worth it to shop. So okay, so how are you gonna shop? Well, you’re gonna go, this is my roadmap for Medicare plan shopping. And first, get organized. Get a list, whether it’s for yourself or a family member. Medication doses. And I say look right at the prescription jar because a lot of us use brand names for medications when we’re on a generic.
So look at the prescription jar and get that written down. If you’re helping a family member, have them take pictures of all their prescriptions, or sometimes the local pharmacy, they can give you a printout of everything And look at those medications. Get a list of your doctors and hospitals and what pharmacy you like to use.
Then the best place to go to shop really is medicare.gov. That’s your second stop. And anymore everybody in Medicare has an account. It’s called My Medicare Account, and if you don’t know it, sign up for it. And what’s cool about that is that it’s already will auto-populate the medications that have been filled on your behalf.
Double-check the list because it’s not 100% accurate. If you have something new, it might not be on the list, but that’s a really easy way to auto-populate your search right within medicare.gov. The search engine anymore is pretty good. It’s, to me, it’s the best place to start. You put your zip code in, and honestly, plans vary down to the county and zip code level.
It does surprise people, so don’t believe, think that, “Well, my friend across the street has this plan,” or, “My friend in the next town has this plan.” First of all, their health might not be yours, and second of all, that plan might not even be available for you. So go in with zip code, have your les- list ahead of time, go into the My Medicare Account, and that’s the easiest way to auto-populate.
The other thing that’s improved over time in the mymedicare.gov site is that you can put your doctors and hospitals in there, and that’ll help you be able to say, “Are my providers in the plan, or are they not in the plan?” So that’s your second step. Then third step is go to the insurance company website.
So you find a plan, whether it’s a Medicare Advantage plan or a drug plan. Medicare.gov is pretty accurate, but things do change over time, and once in a while things are not exactly updated. So I like people to double-check with the actual insurance company site to make sure, yes, these meds are covered, this is the price, these doctors are covered.
And that way you’ll know that you’re getting what you need to get. And right on that site you can apply. You can actually also apply for coverage right on medicare.gov, and you’ll get a confirmation for that. Now, not everybody likes to do things online. You can go on the phone, particularly with the insurance company sites, you can go on the phone with them.
And in a minute we’re gonna show you some really good free resources that are available all over the country for you So the shopping starts with your list. Pull your list together. No matter if you’re looking for an advantage plan or if you’re looking to stay with original Medicare and a drug plan and a Medigap plan How to shop for Medigap.
Medigap is different than a Medicare Advantage plan. You’re gonna have a Part A and a B. You sign up for them, you have your Medicare card. I recommend you get a D plan. But the Medigap, which helps pay for the co-pays and co-insurance, is something you shop for. It’s private insurance regulated by the government, as all insurance is.
There are 11 types of Medigap plans. I’m not gonna detail all 11 to you. I’m gonna say that I recommend Plan G. Some people will recommend another plan or two. Well, okay, think about it carefully if there are exclusions. But Medigap Plan G as in good, is a real solid plan, and it will cover all your co-payments and co-insurance under hospital care, outpatient care, everything except the Medicare Part B deductible, which is $292.
I like their plan ’cause it’s easy to figure out. Things are covered you don’t have to say, “Oh…” ‘Cause some of the other plans don’t cover as much, and so you have to say, “Oh, is this covered? Is that not covered?” The other thing about some of the other Medigap plans is while they don’t cover as much, it’s not necessarily cheaper.
Sometimes they cost more. I don’t know why, but they do. But how do you find a plan? You go to medicare.gov. Again, go look for a Medigap plan. And what I say is they’re also by private insurance, and I recommend solid companies. What, by then I mean the name brand companies you’ve heard of. Don’t go to a plan that you’ve never heard of because it won’t process well for you.
And once in a blue moon, I have seen people whose plans didn’t process their bills well at all, and then they wind up having big bills and still have paid for their Medigap. So look for solid, mainline insurance companies. But then look for the best premium. It’s unbelievable, but a Medicare Medigap G can cost you twice as much with one company or another, or 50% more.
So it’s not very price competitive. Most people don’t know how to look. Now they have upgraded the medicare.gov site so you can see. It used to be they didn’t have the premiums right there. Now they are there for you to see, and just pick solid company but best price because one G plan that costs more than another won’t buy you any more.
So buy the best price. Solid company, best price.
Kathryn Bowie, CFP®: Someone has asked, “If I apply for TRICARE For Life through military pay for Medicare B and get most of my Medicare medical from the VA disability of 90%, do I still need a medical advantage plan?”
Dr. Katy Votava: Okay. Great question. TRICARE For Life is the retired military coverage for people and who…
And the requirement is that you have Medicare A and B, that’s right, and then it will cover almost all of your other costs You really don’t need a Medicare Advantage plan unless there are a few people who live in a part of the country where there isn’t much VA care available and they might want a Medicare Advantage plan.
Most of the time they don’t. Once in a while too, it’ll cover your prescription drug coverage, but depending, you might want a drug plan, a very inexpensive one, because one thing that can be a little tricky with veterans plans is if you needed something short notice, like you had an infection on a weekend, you might have to pay out of pocket.
Is it worth buying a drug plan for that? Not necessarily, but TRICARE For Life can be very, actually more comprehensive. If you have Medicare A and B and TRICARE For Life, that’s really solid coverage, and I find the VA administration and their 800 number to be really user friendly. Great. So, God bless you.
Kathryn Bowie, CFP®: And here’s another one, “We found out last year that our Plan B provider, Blue Shield, doesn’t change offerings and premium until June of the next year. This is outside of the open enrollment period. If I want to change my Plan B provider if I don’t like the June changes, will I be able to do so without penalty?”
Dr. Katy Votava: So it’s a plan… What’s the letter of the alphabet? B as in boy. The, our Plan B provider, Blue Shield. Okay. Plan B provider, now that’s a tricky one, ’cause I’m wondering if they have a Medigap Plan B. Because Part B for Medicare is a standard thing that you sign up for through Social Security.
So if someone has a Blue Cross plan that’s a Plan B, I’m gonna guess it’s a Medigap plan, and Medigap plans can go annually from when you sign up, and Medigap plans are different in terms of annual enrollment is really for Medicare Advantage and for the drug plan. If you have a Medigap plan, most people first of all don’t change plans.
Once in a while people want to upgrade a plan, which can be tricky to do, like a B plan doesn’t cover as much as a G. But you do, you can look around then. The thing is, depending on where you live, only four states in the United States make it relatively easy, to be honest with you, for people to switch Medigap plans.
That’s Connecticut, New York, Massachusetts, I think, and Maine. Otherwise, you have to go through underwriting most of the time. There’s a big exception we’ll talk about in a minute. So don’t worry that it doesn’t, you don’t reevaluate that now. You reevaluate it next year, and most of the people who have those plans will stay with those plans.
If you find out that you’re spending a lot more out of pocket because there are things it doesn’t cover, you might consider upgrading to a different level if you really are in what I’m gonna call is a B Medigap plan. But just look at it every year, and that’s typical with Medigap plans that they don’t have really, they’re really quite separate from annual enrollments.
Kathryn Bowie, CFP®: Okay, thank you. How about one more? “My 65th birthday will be in May of 2027. I’m going to work until 67. We have less than 20 employees, and my employer offers an HSA with EDI. What time is the best time for me to get enrolled in Medicare A, B, and D?”
Dr. Katy Votava: Okay
Kathryn Bowie, CFP®: I am-
Dr. Katy Votava: Well, it’s a, it’s a small employer, 20 or fewer did you say, Kathryn?
Kathryn Bowie, CFP®: It said 20 em- yeah, less than 20 employees
Dr. Katy Votava: Less than 20 employees. The thing is that your employer plan will be secondary from the time you’re 65, and so you really need to go into A and B. When you go into A and B, you cannot contribute new dollars to a health savings account. It’s a law, you cannot do that.
So the question then to me is to, for most people as you go into A and B, you pick up either a D plan and a Medigap plan or you get a Medicare Advantage plan. Now, if it’s a family if it’s a spouse and you have other family members, they can get a, a usually a COBRA coverage for at least 18 months when you leave the plan because honestly, you have to leave the plan because if you stay on the plan…
Now, some people would sign up for the A and the B and just keep the employer coverage as secondary. You could look at what the cost of that is versus just getting A and B and then a D plan and whether it’s a Medigap or Medicare Advantage plan. But Medicare A and B has to be primary because if you get sick and you’re in the hospital, they will bounce your bills out, and I have seen people honestly get hundreds of thousands of dollars clawed back that insurance paid until they realize what’s happening and they’re like, “Well, wait a minute,” and you get billed that.
And that’s way worse than I’m sorry you’ll have to lose the ability to contribute to your health savings account, but that’s… unless your employer decides to hire one more person, and then that could be the primary coverage. Now, this year and every year, people get canceled who are already on Medicare Advantage or prescription drug plans.
M- That’s a little more this year and the last couple of years, but it happens every year. Why? People get nervous. They think they did something wrong, they spent too much money or something. Has nothing to do with you. It has everything to do with the business decision of the insurance company. Now, if a person gets canceled, their plan gets canceled, they actually have extra privileges to sign up, extra time to sign up, and extra options that they may not have had otherwise.
Now, read your notice very carefully. When I find that people get these notices, whether it’s from an insurance company or Social Security or whoever, they’re afraid of them. You get kind of a mental block, but just, you know, take time, read the notice, see what it says. When does your plan end?
Probably if it’s canceled, it goes through the end of December. Sometimes they will MAP you. That means if the insurance company still is operating in the area, they may pick another plan for you. Might not be the best idea for you, but they may MAP you to another plan. You don’t have to accept that but- And what other privileges do you have?
As I mentioned, Medigap. Medigap is a type of coverage that you have guaranteed issue when you first turn 65 or when you first leave an employer plan. Beyond that, in most of the United States, you face underwriting. So if you go into a Medicare Advantage plan, I see people do this, and it’s fine until they get sick, and then they’re finding out they’re spending a whole lot of money out of pocket.
They want to go to a Medigap plan. And if you have to go with underwriting, which means they look at your health plan, sometimes you don’t get approved or sometimes it costs too much. But if you’ve been canceled, your plan was canceled, you have a guaranteed issue right for Medigap. And for a lot of people, that’s a great opportunity, particularly if your healthcare costs have been mounting up, to get into a Medigap plan and then add a D plan to it.
Another of the privileges you have until the end of December to enroll in any Advantage plan or a drug plan to start January 1st You can also have this extended special enrollment period through the end of February. The problem with that is all you’ve had is original Medicare in the meantime, and you won’t have drug coverage, and you won’t have a supplemental.
So really encourage people to pay attention and do their homework and get it done before the end of the year. But even though it can be upsetting to people, it actually could be opportunity for you to get some more comprehensive coverage than you would otherwise be able to get. So take a look at those options.
And I mentioned earlier resources that can help you. These are all free community resources. Eldercare.gov, maybe you have a family member who not only needs health insurance coverage, but you’re trying to figure out what resources are in the area. The one that’s most important with what we’re talking about today is called SHIP Help, the State Health Insurance Assistance Program.
It operates in every county across the United States. It predominantly volunteer, though could be a paid coordinator, and then volunteers were trained. These people don’t work for any insurance company. They will help you figure out what your options are. They’re a great resource. One thing about them, though, is there are only so many of them.
So get on the list now if you need help. They will have community sessions. They’ll be in local libraries or senior centers. But they may set up an individual session for you to figure things out. Another place that really can be helpful, surprising to people, is Medicare, Medicare.gov. They are there 365 days a year, and they do answer the phone.
Sometimes you do have to wait a little bit, but they can actually help you go through your plan options also. But the SHIP Help is really the most available help everywhere. And then if you’re a caregiver, you could be in California and have family member in Iowa, you find out the Iowa SHIP Help and talk to them, and they will help you figure these things out.
So it’s a great resource for you. The other thing is I mentioned here the Medicare section on state health insurance department websites. Every state regulates Medicare Advantage, Medicare Part D and even Medigap, and they will have helpful information for you there. They’ll sometimes even have Medigap pricing information, so that’s a good place to look as well for yourself and your family members Now kind of switching gears a little bit from shopping, but it is important because Medicare is not free.
And Medicare Part B, B as in benefit, and Part D have costs based on income. And this is something you can talk with your advisor about. And I’m not going to belabor this except to say if you’re not aware of this, please be aware that based on your income, you will pay more or less. And this is the 2026 premiums because we don’t know the 2027 Medicare B premium yet.
We think it’s only going up a few bucks. But people who are married filing jointly below $218,000 modified adjusted gross income, which is a whole calculation, your advisor knows all about it, can help you out, or $109,000, you’re gonna pay the base. Anybody above that is gonna pay an income related monthly adjustment amount.
It’s a tax or it’s a sur- surcharge. To participate in Part B, you’ll pay the basic premium and the Part D has an upcharge as well. In addition, you’ll separately pay a premium for Part D. The reason it’s important to know this is to plan ahead. First of all, in any year, they look two years in arrears. So for 2027, they’re going to look at 2025 tax returns.
And particularly around retirement, people can have changes in income, and this is a mistake that a lot of people don’t realize that they don’t just look at your income once. They look at it when you go into Medicare, and they look at it every year after that. So this is where it’s important not to leave money on Medicare’s table, and people make this mistake.
It’s when you first go into Medicare they’re gonna say, if you went in this year, they’re gonna look at 2024. You go in, someone was saying they’re turning 65 next year, they’re gonna look at the 2025 tax return. And if you … Let’s go back here a page here. If you’re even $1 less into the next category- You could save sometimes thousands of dollars or several hundred dollars in a year.
But Social Security doesn’t know your current situation, they only know your situation from two years ago, and you are allowed to tell them. And so when you go into Medicare new, or every fall they send notices out to people currently in Medicare, and when you go in new every fall it says, “This is what you made two years ago.
This is what we’re gonna charge you next year.” And if you’re even $1 lower into the next category given your current circumstances, and these are one of the r- these, these reasons qualify you: people married, divorced or widowed, stop working or reduce work when people retire, lost income/property due to a disaster, and so on.
The most common ones I see are people reducing work and then change in marital stat- status. And right in the notice it tells you the form to file, and you can call if you want to, you can call Social Security because they might want a statement from your financial advisor to say, “Well, this was my income before.”
Or they might n- want a statement from your employer saying, “I’ve retired, I no longer have that income.” But if you apply for a reconsideration within about 60 days, you’ll get it. I’ve honestly never had a person who was qualified, who applied on time, who didn’t get that. And again, when you look at the money you could gain because why leave the money for Medicare when you are not owed it but they don’t know it if you don’t tell them, and you are allowed to tell them.
And every year going forward, particularly in the first couple of years of retirement, sometimes people have, you know, ups and downs in, and sometimes people have higher incomes if they have a payout or something. But just know that you’re gonna look at it every year. And retirement does start a different clock.
It’s a special Part B enrollment period. So we said earlier, if you’re over s- if you’re 65, but you’re still working in, in, in a larger employer and you retire, you have eight months to go into Part B. But what I’ll tell you about that is eight months is a long time. So I recommend people go into Part B right away.
I mean, okay, it gives you eight months to do it and you’re not gonna be in the penalty position, but if you need much healthcare, you’re on your own nickel. So apply right away as soon as you can to Part B. Some people already have A. You can … And the easiest way to do it anymore is to go online. Some people don’t like to deal with online.
Most people do anymore. You go to the My Social Security account, and you apply right there and then, and you will be able to get your Part B in place. ‘Cause until you have Part B, you can’t get a Medigap plan. You cannot get a Med- a Medigap plan or a Medicare Advantage plan. And I would say about when people leave employment, don’t let COBRA bite you because there’s tremendous misunderstanding, and I find well-intended but misinformed people, particularly in companies, they think that, okay, COBRA, you can have it for 18 months.
If you ha- become Medicare eligible, they ha- it has to drop you, and the company doesn’t manage the plan, so frankly they don’t know that. So just be very careful about that, that Medicare has to be primary. Once in a while, I have seen people who already have Medicare, and they stay with the COBRA for family coverage, but most of the time it isn’t really worth it at all.
So do not be surprised about that. Now, if you’re in COBRA coverage, say you retire and you’re 64, and 12 months in you become Medicare eligible, your family member or members will have another eligibility period and be eligible for another 18 months because, and sometimes up to 36 months, because the primary person has become eligible for Medicare.
So those are kind of tricky rules, but just work through them and be careful that you really understand how it’s gonna work. Because otherwise, if you miss your special enrollment period, and I have had people, it’s a shame, who thought COBRA was gonna work, and then they were beyond their special enrollment period, and they have a penalty for life, and they have to wait to get coverage, and, you know, that’s no way to start your retirement.
N- no way at all. And here is the penalties that we talk about. Part A, B, and D, you’ve gotta have those parts, and if you don’t apply for Part B in time or Part D, here’s the penalties. Part B is 10% per year for every year you didn’t have the coverage. The average number of years that people don’t apply, believe it or not, is three years.
So you could pay 30%, you will pay 30% per year more for your Part B coverage, and you can’t get rid of that cost. And 30% on $200 a month, you know, that’s, you know, $260 a month for the rest of your life. Or if your spouse is, you’re both going to pay that, that penalty if you were not in on time. And for Part D as in drug, the penalty is 1% per month for every month you didn’t have coverage.
So again, 36% more on your Part D premium if you’re late. And the worst penalty, I think, and I’ve seen this happen particularly when it comes to D, people will be kind of cavalier and say, “Nah, I don’t take medications. I’m not gonna sign up for Part D.” And then they become seriously ill with very expensive medications, and there’s a delay till they can get the coverage.
And in the meantime, if you really need something and you have to spend honestly $100,000, that’s what it’s gonna cost you. And there’s no point in that because Part D you can find a very economical plan. You may wanna change it down the road if it doesn’t cover your co- your medications very well but don’t get caught in a penalty ’cause that’s a shame and that’s a waste of your money, and you’ve worked too hard for your retirement money, and your advisors don’t want that to happen to you either.
That’s why we’re here talking today. Do know that your current plan deserves a fresh look. A lot of people think, “Eh, it’s okay,” or, “I don’t have time.” And also, we get into the holidays. We get into the Thanksgiving and then into the winter holidays. What I like to say is I like people, if they can, get their shopping done before Thanksgiving.
Because from Thanksgiving on through December, there’s just so much going on, and there really isn’t that much time. December 7th is pretty early for most of us. So pay attention to it now. And again, it’s medications and care providers. Those are two separate things that you have to look at. But you don’t even need to know how to spell hemochromatosis or something fancy like that.
Just get a list and check. You know, it’s like doing your shopping. Make a list and check it twice, and you will be much happier for that in the long run for yourselves and your family members. We’re back here to our free resources here. I think it’s always important to remember that there is help out there, and what’s surprising to me sometimes is how h- there’s help out there, and it doesn’t even get used.
So don’t make that mistake. Don’t feel like you don’t know or, you know. Have your family member go to the community center, bring their medications in their little bag, and have them get them out when it’s the day that they’re going to help people check. Another place that’s not even on here is your community pharmacies.
They already know your medications that you’re taking. Many of them now will help
Kathryn Bowie, CFP®: you
Dr. Katy Votava: run the analysis and say, “Here’s a coverage that’s going to work for you.” So ask your pharmacist, are they offering plan evaluations? And they don’t offer the coverage, but they do help figure it. ‘Cause I think it actually helps them get their clients covered.
Here’s worth mentioning. Medicare costs a lot of money. Not everybody has the money for it. If you or your family member needs help paying, there is help out there. There is extra help for Part D because $2,400 a year, if you remember that slide I had early on, that’s a lot of money after premium. That’s a lot of money.
But many states and localities have additional resources to help people pay their co-pays and Medicare Part D. Then there’s some other things called Medicare savings plan- plans. They’re, they come through the Social Security Administration, but they’re actually administered at the state level, and you can apply for those.
And again, your SHIP program, they will help you figure out if you’re eligible for that. And the eligibility, it’s, you know, it’s a whole set of factors. It varies by state. But when you are helping your family members out, and you’re saying, “That’s okay, Mom, I’ll pick up the prescriptions,” and it’s costing you a couple hundred, a couple, a few more than $100, do look around to see if there’s assistance for people, ’cause a lot of times there really might be for people.
So your Medicare action list is do your homework, get her done, and then move on till- Things are so you don’t have to feel like this guy. And here’s the dos Enroll on time, for sure. Look for coverage that fits and shop every year. It really makes a difference. If you don’t shop every year, this year for sure you should shop.
But I say at least every two to three years because the industry knows people don’t shop and costs go up about 40%. So save yourself some money and do not assume you can’t do better because you really can and if you don’t look, you won’t know. And honestly, more and more on Medicare.g- only it’s pretty straightforward to do it.
So I’m gonna turn it back over to Kathryn to see if there are more questions here.
Kathryn Bowie, CFP®: What Medicare decisions or selections are changeable during the open enrollment period and which are decisions are for a lifetime, if any?
Dr. Katy Votava: The decisions that are specifically changeable during annual enrollment are Medicare Advantage plans and Part D plans.
The things that don’t change are your Medicare A and B. When you’re in, they don’t change. The premium might change for B over the years and usually Medigap doesn’t change over time. It can but not that often.
Kathryn Bowie, CFP®: Okay. And can we change our Medigap Plan G plan to another Medigap Plan G? Is there more than one Plan G?
Dr. Katy Votava: There’s only one set of benefits for Plan G and it’ll be the same benefits at every company.
Kathryn Bowie, CFP®: Okay.
Dr. Katy Votava: The only time I’ve had people ch- change companies was really once when the company that they had was, I’m gonna call it a, a no-name brand company and it wasn’t… they weren’t doing a good job for them, weren’t paying the bills.
But generally, you don’t switch company to company and in most of, many parts of the United States it’s actually hard to do because underwriting rules to change, but you can try. Doesn’t mean you can’t but most of the time unless you have a plan… I have had people whose plans were really expensive and they didn’t realize that they could get the same thing for much less money.
You can certainly apply. Do not cancel your current coverage till you’re accepted into a new coverage.
Kathryn Bowie, CFP®: Good point.
Dr. Katy Votava: All right.
Kathryn Bowie, CFP®: What are your thoughts on working with groups like Chapter to determine low-cost options for Medicare?
Dr. Katy Votava: My thoughts on working with groups like Chapter?
Kathryn Bowie, CFP®: I’m not sure what Chapter is.
Dr. Katy Votava: I’m not sure what Chapter is. If someone wants to chime in. Is it a f- there are faith-based groups out there? Does the Medigap plan cover the cost of higher tier expensive drugs when you have
a Medigap? Medigap Medigap plan only covers co-payments and co-insurance that would be part of Part A like hospitalization or outpatient care and laboratory.
Part D prescription drug plan, there’s nothing else you can buy. Medigap does not pay any more for any Part D plan or any medication. So the thing to do with Part D is really shop. Make sure that your plan is the best for you because your medication could be expensive in one plan and much more economical in another plan.
So the Part D shopping, whether you have a- In part of a Medicare Advantage plan or Part D plan is really important
Kathryn Bowie, CFP®: Okay. If you already, if you are already in a Medicare Advantage plan, can you move to Medigap plan during open enrollment? And it’s com- I’m combining these two questions ’cause another one says, “Can you confirm that if you choose Medicare Advantage plan that you cannot go back into a Part B plan if you choose to do so later?”
So just a quick example.
Dr. Katy Votava: Okay. Two sides of that coin. If you’re in a Medicare Advantage plan and you wanna go to a Medigap plan plus a drug plan, my recommendation is you apply for the Medigap plan right away, get accepted so you’ll know you can get it, and then apply for a drug plan, and then you’ll be able to drop the Advantage plan.
If you’re in a Medigap plan and you decide you wanna go to Medicare Advantage, you can do that, and it’s… You can change it the next year as long as you can get back in. Because again, underwriting for Medigap is a real issue in most of the United States. And so bec- I don’t find many people leaving Medigap to go to Medicare Advantage.
You can, and you can come back. I do find people who are in Medicare Advantage who want to go to a Medigap. And they… There is another time in the year, the first quarter of next year, there is a special Medicare Advantage open enrollment period. Not a lot of people know about it, but if you don’t get your shopping done now, and particularly with the Medigap thing, is January 1st through the end of March, you can apply for a Medigap plan, get accepted, then leave the Advantage plan and sign up for a D, and then you could do it that way well, as well if you don’t get your shopping done in the fall.
But it’s a sequencing thing.
Kathryn Bowie, CFP®: They signed up for Medicare Plan A, still working for a couple of years. Do I need to send Medicare any proof of employment or anything like that to avoid the penalties when I later sign up for the rest of Medicare? I work for a company that has more than 20 employees.
Dr. Katy Votava: When you…
So the person already has Medicare Part A. At such time in the future when they wanna add B, they will at that time fill out a request to add B, and the employer will need to sign off that you have had creditable coverage during that period of time. That’s the time to do it, is when you sign up for the B, not before.
Kathryn Bowie, CFP®: Thank you
Dr. Katy Votava: so much- Thank you, Kathy …
Kathryn Bowie, CFP®: for your time. We so appreciate you, and we appreciate everyone who’s been on our webinar. My pleasure. Everyone have a wonderful day
Subscribe to our YouTube channel.
IMPORTANT DISCLOSURES:
- Neither Pure Financial Advisors nor the presenter is affiliated or endorsed by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) or affiliated with the United States government or any other governmental agency.
- This material is for information purposes only and is not intended as tax, legal, or investment recommendations.
- Consult your tax advisor for guidance. Tax laws and regulations are complex and subject to change.
- Investment Advisory and Financial Planning Services are offered through Pure Financial Advisors, LLC an SEC Registered Investment Advisor.
- All information is believed to be from reliable sources; however, we make no representation as to its completeness or accuracy.
- Pure Financial Advisors is not affiliated with Attorney Nicole Newman. References in this material to Attorney Nicole Newman does not constitute or imply endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by Pure Financial Advisors nor its employees.
CFP® – The CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER® certification is by the CFP Board of Standards, Inc. To attain the right to use the CFP® mark, an individual must satisfactorily fulfill education, experience and ethics requirements as well as pass a comprehensive exam. 30 hours of continuing education is required every 2 years to maintain the certification. Esq. – Esquire (Esq.) is an honorary title that is placed after a practicing lawyer’s name. Practicing lawyers are those who have passed a state’s (or Washington, D.C.’s) bar exam and have been licensed by that jurisdiction’s bar association.




